How to Get Your Agency to Show Up in AI Search Results

Spencer Breidenbach, BrightFire’s Manager of Strategic Partnerships, joined Abe Boling on The Insurance Dream Podcast to share how insurance agencies can show up in AI search results.

Read the summary below, or listen to the full episode from The Insurance Dream here.

Podcast Episode Summary

I. Introduction

  • Spencer cuts through the AI hype to show how consumers really use ChatGPT and Gemini to shop for insurance, and how agencies can show up in their answers.

II. How consumers search now

  • AI is built into Google search
    • AI Overviews answer early questions like “Do I need flood insurance?” before any link appears.
    • Agencies that AI doesn’t understand or trust are invisible at that moment.
  • Local searches still go to the Map Pack
    • “Near me,” city, and zip code searches still rely on your Google Business Profile, reviews, and proximity.
    • The change is in the research phase, where AI shapes opinions and narrows the choices.
  • Consumers are comfortable with AI
    • 37% start their searches with AI (Search Engine Land), and 47% have used AI while shopping online (Adobe).
    • People are frustrated with too many links and ads, and they expect clear, fast answers.
  • ChatGPT and insurance
    • ChatGPT handles millions of P&C questions and returns local results like “best home insurance agents in [city].”

III. Case studies in ChatGPT

  • Restaurant insurance question: ChatGPT explains coverages in plain language, asks follow-up questions, and outlines next steps. Prospects arrive already educated.
  • Adding a location: “I’m in Georgia, where should I get quotes?” brings back named independent agencies with links. A short list can form without a Google search, so the question is whether AI recommends your agency.

IV. Where SEO and AEO (answer engine optimization) overlap

  • Google and ChatGPT results look alike: A Woodstock, GA search showed many of the same agencies, with matching review ratings, in both.
  • AI works like a research assistant: It summarizes public information. There’s no black box.
  • Trust signals: Consistent name, address, and phone number everywhere, a current Google Business Profile, local mentions, and detailed reviews
  • Show, don’t tell: AI favors facts it can check, like “Founded in 1998” or “Licensed in three states,” and specific reviews.
  • Website structure: Use schema markup (LocalBusiness, FAQ, Service, Person) and a clean H1 to H3 heading hierarchy so AI can follow your site.

V. What’s unique to AEO

  • Conversational content: Write FAQs the way people ask, like “Why is homeowners insurance so expensive in Georgia?”
  • Entity clarity: Spell out who you are, what you offer, where, and who you serve. Skip vague claims like “the best coverage.”
  • Off-site signals: Mentions from community groups, trade groups, and partners count. Consider an “Our Local Partners” page.
  • LLMS.TXT: A new, unofficial file that guides AI to your most important content. BrightFire already uses it.

VI. BrightFire’s AI tools

  • Social Media Marketing: Done-for-you posting, plus AI help with post ideas, hashtags, rewrites, replies, and timing
  • Review and Reputation Management: AI-drafted review replies
  • Insurance Agency Websites: Custom, easy-to-navigate sites (75% of consumers judge credibility by website design). AI text and image generation for pages, blogs, and bios is coming later this year.

Questions?

If you have questions about the episode or how BrightFire’s digital marketing solutions can help your agency show up in AI search results, schedule a personalized consultation with a Sales Advisor.

Share this post

We're here to help!